A Singular Point of View
If your attention feels as though it has been cut into small pieces and handed out to whatever buzzes first, this one is for you. Two experiments suggest you can have some of those pieces back without throwing the phone in a drawer.
A tap on the shoulder, all day long
Picture someone standing just behind your chair from the moment you wake. Every few minutes they lean in and tap you on the shoulder. A message from the family group at ten past seven. A delivery update while you are brushing your teeth. A news alert halfway through the sentence you are typing for work, then “someone liked your photo” just as your child starts telling you about their day. None of the taps is urgent. Each one pulls you a few inches out of what you were doing, and each time you have to find your own way back.
That person is your phone. And it does not stop.
Nicholas Fitz, the Duke University researcher who led one of the two studies below, has put the average at somewhere between 65 and 80 notifications a day. That is not a phone ringing now and then. That is a companion who never stops clearing their throat.
If you have reached twenty past four on an ordinary Wednesday, read the same email for the third time and still not taken it in, you may have blamed stress, age, poor sleep or simply being “bad at concentrating”. Any of those can play a part. But two careful experiments, both involving the psychologist Kostadin Kushlev, point to something smaller and far easier to change. Not the phone itself, but the way it interrupts you.
The first experiment: a week on, a week off
In 2016, Kushlev, then at the University of Virginia, worked with Jason Proulx and Elizabeth Dunn at the University of British Columbia on a study they titled, quite bluntly, “Silence Your Phones”. They recruited 221 students from the general student population, not a clinical group, and asked them to live two different weeks.
In one week, the students were told to maximise interruptions: alerts switched on, phone kept within reach and within sight. In the other, they were told to minimise them: alerts off, phone tucked away. At the end of each week they filled in questionnaires measuring inattention and hyperactivity, the two clusters of symptoms used to describe ADHD (attention deficit hyperactivity disorder).
The difference was clear. During the alerts-on week, the students reported significantly more inattention and more hyperactivity. And the inattention mattered beyond itself: higher levels of it predicted lower productivity and lower psychological wellbeing.
Bring that into your own week. The restlessness you have put down to your personality, the way you pick up the phone while the kettle boils and then forget why you came into the kitchen, may partly be a response to surroundings that keep breaking your concentration for you.
What it does not mean
Kushlev was careful here, and it is worth being careful with it too. His team’s findings, he said, suggest neither that smartphones can cause ADHD nor that cutting notifications can treat it. ADHD is a neurodevelopmental condition, meaning one rooted in how the brain develops, with complex biological and environmental causes. What the study showed is that constant interruption can produce ADHD-like symptoms in ordinary students, and that those symptoms ease when the interruptions are turned down.
If you are waiting for an ADHD assessment, have just come away with a diagnosis, or are holding a letter from school about your child’s concentration, keep hold of that distinction. This research cannot tell you whether you or your child has ADHD. It can tell you that the phone is probably not helping, whoever you are.
Why a buzz is so hard to ignore
The second study opens with a comparison that is hard to shake once you have heard it: notifications are often likened to slot machines. The researchers point to a long line of work, going back to B. F. Skinner’s experiments on reward, showing that rewards arriving at unpredictable moments are the ones that keep a creature pressing the lever.
Most of what your phone delivers is dull. But every so often there is something good in there: a message from someone you love, news you were waiting for, a small piece of approval. You never know which buzz will be the good one, so every buzz gets checked. Your attention is not weak. It has been trained, very effectively, by a system built to capture it.
There is a second cost, too. In a well-known study published in Science in 2010, the Harvard researchers Matthew Killingsworth and Daniel Gilbert used a phone app to ask people, at random moments, what they were doing and whether their mind was on it. Minds were wandering in 46.9 per cent of the samples, and people were less happy when their minds wandered than when they did not. Every notification is an invitation for your mind to leave the room it is in.
How many times has your phone lit up since you started reading this? And how many of those times did you look?
The second experiment: three times a day
If the first study showed that interruptions cost you something, the second asked a more useful question. What can you actually do about it, short of switching everything off?
In 2019, Nicholas Fitz and Kostadin Kushlev, with colleagues at Duke University’s Center for Advanced Hindsight including the behavioural economist Dan Ariely, published a randomised field experiment in the journal Computers in Human Behavior. A randomised experiment is one in which people are put into groups by chance, so that differences between the groups can more fairly be put down to the thing being tested. Using an app on their Android phones, the team changed how 237 smartphone users in India received their notifications over two weeks.
Each participant was placed in one of four groups:
- As usual: notifications arrived whenever they arrived.
- Hourly: notifications were held back and delivered in one batch every hour.
- Three times a day: everything was held back and delivered in three batches, at 9am, 3pm and 9pm.
- Never: no notifications at all.
Each day, participants answered short diary surveys about how they felt, and the app recorded how often they unlocked their phones.
The middle way won
The three-times-a-day group came out ahead. Compared with people getting notifications as usual, they felt more attentive, more productive, in a better mood, less stressed and more in control of their phones. They also unlocked their phones fewer times a day, which matters because the app measured that directly rather than relying on what people said about themselves.
The hourly group barely differed from the as-usual group. Getting your messages every hour turned out to be much like getting them whenever they came.
And the group with no notifications at all? They did not find peace. They reported more anxiety and more fear of missing out, often shortened to FoMO.
That is the finding to keep. Switching everything off did not work. Taking charge of the timing did.
Before you rearrange your whole life around this
Here I want to slow down for a moment. These limits are not a footnote for researchers. They are here so that you do not throw out a habit that already works for you, and so that you do not blame yourself if three windows a day turns out harder than the headline made it sound.
They were short. One study ran for a week in each condition, the other for two weeks. Nobody yet knows whether the benefits last for months, fade as the novelty wears off, or grow as new habits settle. Fitz himself has said people might adjust differently over a longer stretch. If week three feels different from week one, that is not you failing. It is ground the research has not covered.
Most of the measures were self-reported. People told the researchers how attentive, stressed or happy they felt. That counts for something, but it is not the same as an objective test of concentration. In the 2016 study, the students knew which week they were in, and knowing you are in the “phone away” week can colour how you answer.
The groups were particular. The first study recruited students at a Canadian university. The second recruited Android users in India, because Apple did not allow that level of control over notifications. You may be neither, and your days may look nothing like theirs.
Batching is not completely cost-free. One summary of the 2019 findings notes that even the three-times-a-day group felt somewhat more worried about missing out than the as-usual group. If you notice that itch, it is a known side effect, not a sign you are doing it wrong.
The ADHD question is an extension. Neither study tested people with a diagnosis of ADHD. If you live with ADHD, it is reasonable to think that interruptions which scatter other people’s attention will weigh at least as heavily on yours. But that is an inference, not a finding, and you deserve to be told so plainly.
None of this cancels the results. It means you are running a promising experiment on your own life, with your own evidence, rather than following a cure.
Running the experiment on yourself
What both studies share is a refreshingly practical message. You do not need to give up your phone. You need to stop it deciding when you pay attention. Here is a way to start this week.
Do a two-minute audit tonight. Open your notification settings and scroll through every app that is allowed to interrupt you. For each one, ask yourself whether you would miss it if it waited until later. Switch off anything that is selling you something, anything from a game, and anything that tells you someone has “reacted”.
Choose your three windows. The study used 9am, 3pm and 9pm. Yours might be breakfast, lunch and after the washing-up. On an iPhone, the Scheduled Summary option in notification settings gathers non-urgent alerts and delivers them at times you choose. Most Android phones offer Do Not Disturb schedules or a Focus mode in their Digital Wellbeing settings.
Keep a short list of people who always get through. Your child’s school, whoever looks after an elderly parent, your partner. Batching is about timing, not cutting yourself off, and the no-notifications group shows why a total blackout can backfire.
Move the phone, not just the setting. The 2016 study paired silencing with keeping the phone out of reach. When you need to concentrate, put it in another room or a bag, face down, rather than on the desk beside your hand.
Turn off the badges. The little red numbers on app icons are a silent notification of their own. Removing them stops a quick glance at the home screen turning into a ten-minute detour.
Give it two weeks. That was the length of the 2019 trial. In the first few days, notice how often your hand goes to your pocket, without marking yourself down for it. That reaching is the old habit loosening, not proof that you have failed.
If it helps to see it laid out, here is one shape your day could take:
| Time | What happens |
|---|---|
| Morning window (e.g. 8–8.15am) | Check everything that has gathered overnight. Reply to what needs replying to. |
| Morning to lunchtime | Phone silent and out of sight while you work, study or look after the house. Calls from your short list still come through. |
| Lunchtime window (e.g. 1–1.15pm) | Second batch. Messages, news, social media if you want it. |
| Afternoon to evening | Back to silence. Notice how long you can stay with one task. |
| Evening window (e.g. 7–7.30pm) | Final batch of the day, then the phone charges away from the bedside if you can manage it. |
If you live with ADHD, or love someone who does
This is worth trying, with honest expectations. Batching will not replace an assessment, medication, coaching or support at school. What it can do is remove one source of interference from a mind that already has plenty to manage. If you have ADHD, you may find the hardest part is not starting a task but getting back to it after something has pulled you away. Every notification you switch off is one less road back you have to find.
If it is your child, choose the windows with them rather than handing them down. A plan they helped design is one they are far more likely to keep.
Your attention belongs to you
Most of the forces shaping your mental health are large and slow: work, money, relationships, the news. This one is small. It sits in your pocket, and you can change it before you go to bed tonight.
The research does not ask you to become a different person, or to give up the tools that keep you close to the people you care about. It asks for something more modest. Decide when the world gets to tap you on the shoulder. Three times a day, perhaps. The rest of the time, your attention is yours, for the conversation in front of you, the page you are writing, the child telling you about their day.
Open your settings tonight and choose your three windows. Then give yourself two quieter weeks, and see what comes back.
Source: Kushlev, K., Proulx, J. D. E. and Dunn, E. W. (2016) “‘Silence Your Phones’: Smartphone Notifications Increase Inattention and Hyperactivity Symptoms”, Proceedings of the 2016 CHI Conference on Human Factors in Computing Systems, pp. 1011–1020; and Fitz, N., Kushlev, K., Jagannathan, R., Lewis, T., Paliwal, D. and Ariely, D. (2019) “Batching smartphone notifications can improve well-being”, Computers in Human Behavior, 101, pp. 84–94, December 2019. Additional context: Killingsworth, M. A. and Gilbert, D. T. (2010) “A wandering mind is an unhappy mind”, Science.

Leave a Reply